Jump to content

Arthur-A

Members
  • Content Count

    362
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Arthur-A

  1. It can be turned off in the settings.
  2. How about more adequate FM, better DM and overall better looks? This sim has it all. I'll take those any day over canopy raindrops and scratches.
  3. I hope everything will go as planned and we'll get VR support after the 5.0 is released. But still, even without it I really enjoy this sim! Can't wait for the Tobruk expansion. I like the FM and DM more in CloD than in.. other sims. Feels way more realistic and close to real life videos. And performance with all the settings maxed out is super smooth. Future is bright for this sim, it has a tremendous potential. I wish Team Fusion a great success and hope that we'll enjoy various theaters and aircraft in this awesome sim.
  4. Arthur-A

    P-47

    It all began when I started an Operation Bodenplatte career, I choose my favorite US fighter - P-47. It felt wrong. You can't dogfight in it nor you can run away, even on 15 minute combat power. I'm not talking about boosted mode, since the timer is only 5 minutes which in most cases won't be enough to run away. Then I did some duels in QMB in P-47 and A-20 against a Bf-109 G14. The results are attached as track files. There are only two of them, one for P-47 and the other one for A-20. I did more duels, but the results are similar to those ones on the tracks. A-20 can catch up with the 109 easily in a climb, can successfully turn with it. The Jug.. well, judge for yourselves. Just want to mention. For A-20 I used 50% fuel, outlet cowls are 100% open. For the Jug - 30% fuel, inlet cowls closed, Intercooler and oil cooler are set to 50% (neutral). Something is terribly wrong here.. A20vs109G14.zip Due to 5mb limit, I'm uploading P-47 track as a separate post. P47vs109G14.zip
  5. Yeah, it's understandable that at low altitude the Jug is at disadvantage. But to what degree? Is it really that bad so that even A20 with full fuel load is a better dogfighter? And even at high alts it's not convincing either.
  6. Over BoN as well. And if you add those engine timers.. you may notice that the cloud stretches even more.
  7. For those who complain I suggest the devs place a few of those on the airfields. So that they'll appreciate the feature, lol.
  8. It would be interesting to know his comments after trying several planes, especially setting up a dogfight in QMB against a 109. And comparing P-47 to A-20 in a dogfight against the 109. Wonder what his impressions would be.
  9. So it's faster when it's fully open at 10000 m? I just did another test in 1946. I flew A20G (there's no A20B, but it should be relatively close) against G14 at 500 m. It was completely different experience compared to GB. While in GB every time I was able to outturn him and get on his 6, I was able to catch up with him both horizontally and in a climb, in 1946 however, I couldn't outturn him, I couldn't follow him horizontally and in a climb. That behavior for me is more realistic for a medium bomber rather than how it behaves in GB. What's weird is, in 1946 A20G I kind of felt the same as I felt in a P-47 in GB.
  10. Tried again at 10000 meters. I managed to get on his 6, but I wouldn't say that the P-47 had an obvious advantage. Acceleration and speed was about on par, but he was still more maneuverable than me. In 1946 the Jug is clearly superior at 10000 m. And I've just tried P-47 D27 vs Bf-109 G14 at 500 meters in 1946. It wasn't easy to win a turn fight, but power wise it didn't feel like a pig. I got on his 6 and shot him down. It was impossible in BoX. So in 1946 you can feel that the Jug is heavy and it's hard to turn with a 109, but it's not that helpless.
  11. Oh, forgot the mixture, but it is set to Auto Rich by default if you spawn in the air.
  12. Let's see what am I missing: Throttle? 100% Engine RPM? 100% Turbo RPM? ~20000 RPM Intercooler flaps? Neutral Cowl flaps? Fully closed Oil cooler flaps? Neutral Oh yeah, and I used boost mode. Still 109 was faster.
  13. I suspect there's something very wrong in how the P-47 is modeled in this sim if I can perfectly outclimb and outturn a G14 in 1946 at 10000 meters, while in this sim I can't. While the AI is harder to fight against in 1946, not in this sim. This story reminds me the situation with the P-40. When it was released it had a bunch of flaws in it's FM, flew like a brick and a lot of people complained, only then devs revised it's FM and now it flies like it should (except for those damn engine timers).
  14. Well, I flew against G14 at 10000 meters yesterday - same thing. Jug was helpless, couldn't outclimb and outturn it even at 10000 meters! So a medium bomber being a much better dogfighter than a P-47 is historically correct? I don't know what to say.. I did the same test P-47 against G14 in 1946 both at 500 and 10000 meters. At 500 meters it wasn't easy to beat the 109, but I wouldn't say that it was too hard. I shot it down several times. At 10000 it was even easier. It was clearly obvious that P-47 has great advantage over the 109 at 10000 meters. Don't forget that the AI in 1946 is a beast compared to the GB, however, it wasn't that hard to shoot down a 109 in a Jug, while in GB it's nearly impossible. I'm not saying that my flying skills are any good, but I'm sure that the Jug in the old sim is much more convincing. Yes, it also feels quite heavy and way less nimble than a 109, but it's not helpless against it. Those are my facts, I suggest anyone to try themselves. Both scenarios in GB and in 1946 and share your experience. And try dogfighting 109 in A-20 too.
  15. Yeah, A-20 suits that role better, I just tried.
  16. Ok, so I did QMB duels against G14 at 500 meters. When I was in P-47 he danced around me and I couldn't do anything. He outturned and outclimbed me. I wasn't able to get on his 6. Ok, but then I choose A-20 and it was the opposite! I was able to outturn him, outclimb him, very quickly got on his 6 and shot him down. What pissed me off the most is that I could easily catch up with him in A-20, but it was almost impossible in a Jug. This is ridiculous. When you're able to easily shot down a 109 in a medium bomber, but it's almost impossible to dogfight it in a Jug - something's wrong. I'm not going to touch P-47 in this sim again, until devs fix those issues. And for the first time, I'm starting to regret pre-ordering BON. See, P-47 was the first allied aircraft released for the Bodenplatte. More than 2 years ago. Devs had plenty of time to fix all those issues and yet it still remains half-assed. Kinda sucks, especially if it's your favorite US fighter.
  17. That's the most reasonable limitation for the WEP I could ever imagine. However, I can't think of it like that when I look at the temp gauges and see that water and oil temps are just fine. This is not a simulation then. It's a weird arcade where instead of simplifying things they artificially make them harder. By the way, how long does it take to cool down the engine? Does it take 5, 10 or 15 minutes? If I overheat it, I open all the rads, ease on the throttle and it cools down within 1 or 2 minutes. Then again, I can't imagine that a plane would be cleared for use if it allowed pilot to use a power setting that would destroy the engine within couple of minutes or less (109s and P-39/40). At least the devs could make an alternative setting where all WEP would be limited to at least 30 min. And let us decide.
  18. But how come that time can be recharged then?
  19. This sim is plagued by the engine timers. They have to go!
  20. Yes, it will definitely be a limiting factor in future. I like the option of having a discount for those who already own some aircraft included in future expansions.
  21. It's bad even at high altitude in this sim.
  22. Dude, I was about to start a similar topic myself. I've started a Bodenplatte Career, flew 2 missions - the P-47 in this sim is a joke! It's a pig made of glass. What's even more funny - I ran a Quick Mission on 10000m in P-47 against a Bf-109 G14. So at that altitude the Jug has to run circles around the 109, right? Wrong! The 109 could outclimb and outturn me. This is ridiculous! Even down low it's too porked. I'm going to run some experiments tomorrow, fly quick mission battles in Il-2 and A20 against 109s and compare it to the Jug. But I already imagine the results. IMHO, the Jug is incomplete and needs serious rework in both it's FM and DM. I ran the similar quick mission in 1946 in P-47 D27 against Bf-109 G14 at 10000 meters. I ran circles around it. Even though the AI in 1946 is even better than in BOX. I think it pretty much sums it up.
×
×
  • Create New...